Which works best for stubborn depression? adding a drug, brain stimulation, or switching meds?
NCT ID NCT02977299
First seen Jul 09, 2026 · Last updated Jul 10, 2026 · Updated 1 time
Summary
This trial studies three approaches for adults with major depression that hasn't responded to standard antidepressants. Participants either add aripiprazole (Abilify) to their current medication, add repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), or switch to venlafaxine XR (Effexor XR). The goal is to see which strategy best reduces depressive symptoms and improves quality of life.
What this could mean
Our plain-language read of the trial. This is informational only, not medical advice or a prediction.
- Active substance
- Aripiprazole, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), venlafaxine XR
- What this could lead to
- If successful, this could help doctors choose the most effective next-step treatment for people whose depression hasn't improved with standard antidepressants.
- What could go wrong
- This is a Phase 4 trial comparing existing treatments, so no new breakthrough is expected. Results may show only modest differences between options, and individual responses vary.
This is an AI summary of the original study and may miss details. Read our disclaimer.
Study facts
What this study's own registry entry says, in plain language.
- Phase
-
Phase 4
Runs after approval, following long-term safety and how well the treatment works in everyday use.
- Participants
-
278 people
The number who actually took part.
- Started
-
Jul 2017
- Finished
-
Apr 2022
- Lead sponsor
-
Other sponsor
The registry's catch-all category, for sponsors it does not file as a company, a government agency, or a research network.
Who can take part
This study's own entry requirements. Only the study team can say for certain whether you qualify.
- Ages
-
18 to 80 years
- Sex
-
Anyone
- Healthy volunteers
-
Not accepted
This study is not open to healthy volunteers. The entry requirements below say who it is open to.
Show the full entry requirements Hide the full entry requirements
Copied word for word from the study's registry entry, so the wording is the study team's rather than ours.
Inclusion Criteria: 1. women and men ages 18-80, 2. with MDD, of at least 12 weeks duration, according to Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) criteria confirmed by the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI; Sheehan et al, 1998), 3. have a Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS - Montgomery and Asberg, 1979) score of at least 20 at screen and baseline as assessed by site clinicians, 4. meet criteria for TRD during the current major depressive episode documented in the MGH Antidepressant Treatment History Questionnaire (ATRQ) (Chandler et al., 2010), which will be defined as being non-responders (less than 50% of symptom improvement) to two or more depression treatment trials of adequate dose and duration as defined by the MGH ATRQ, 5. are currently on an antidepressant of adequate dose (as defined by the MGH ATRQ) and duration (at least 8 weeks), with the antidepressant dose being stable over the past four weeks, and with documented (in the MGH ATRQ) non-response (less than 50% improvement) to the current antidepressant. 6. Patients who have passed the MGH CTNI remote assessment, with documentation provided to sites by MGH CTNI. Exclusion Criteria: 1. pregnant or breastfeeding women, women of childbearing potential who are not using an accepted means of birth control, or women with a positive urine pregnancy test, 2. patients who have received treatment with rTMS, aripiprazole, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), or venlafaxine during the current episode, 3. patients who express an objection to receiving treatment with at least one of the three treatment arms of our study, 4. patients with any history of bipolar disorder or psychosis (diagnosed by MINI), 5. patients with active alcohol or substance abuse disorders within the past 6 months (diagnosed by MINI), 6. patients with suicidal ideation of the degree that, in the opinion of the evaluating clinician, participation in the study would place them at significantly increased risk of suicide, 7. patients with unstable medical issues of such degree that, in the opinion of the evaluating clinician, participation in the study would place them at significant risk of a serious adverse event, or patients with a screening hemoglobin A1c level greater than 7.5%, or patients with epilepsy, dementia, Parkinson's disease, or Huntington's Disease, 8. patients who have received treatment with vagus nerve stimulation (VNS), 9. patients who have not responded to more than five FDA-approved antidepressant treatment trials of adequate dose and duration during the current episode, or who did not respond to ECT in previous episodes 10. patients on excluded medications, 11. patients with a positive urine screen drug test for a substance for which they do not have a valid prescription for a valid medical reason, 12. patients with currently abnormal thyroid function tests, 13. patients who have received at least one dose of a monoamine oxidase inhibitor (MAOI) four weeks or less prior, and 14. for patients on concomitant psychotropic agents (anticonvulsants, benzodiazepines, hypnotics, opiates, triiodothyronine (T3), modafinil, psychostimulants, buspirone, melatonin, omega-3 fatty acids, folate, l-methylfolate, s-adenosyl methionine, lithium) not on the same dose for at least four weeks prior to study entry or who do not agree to continue at the same dose during the acute phase of the study. 15. Patients who do not meet safety criteria for TMS: history of seizures, cardiac pacemaker, DBS or VNS, brain aneurism clips or other metallic implants in the intracranial space. 16. Also excluded is an individual who has received any administration of ketamine in the current episode for the treatment of depression.
Get updates
Get notified about this study
Sign up to get updates when this study changes or when new studies for Treatment-resistant major depressive disorder are added.
By submitting, you agree to our Terms of use
Conditions
The condition(s) this trial relates to.
As listed by the trial registrant
The condition terms exactly as the trial's registrant entered them.
Contacts and locations
Locations
-
Baylor College of Medicine
Houston, Texas, 77030, United States
-
New York University
New York, New York, 10003, United States
-
Northwestern University, Feinberg School of Medicine
Chicago, Illinois, 60611, United States
-
Pacific Institute of Medical Research
Los Angeles, California, 90095, United States
-
Roper St. Francis Hospital
Charleston, South Carolina, 29425, United States
-
Stanford University
Stanford, California, 94305, United States
-
The University of Alabama School of Medicine
Birmingham, Alabama, 35294, United States
-
University of British Columbia
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
-
University of Cincinnati
Cincinnati, Ohio, 45219, United States
-
University of Manitoba St. Boniface Hospital
Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2H 2A6, Canada
-
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 19104, United States
-
University of South Florida
Tampa, Florida, 33613, United States
-
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
Dallas, Texas, 75390, United States
More trials for these conditions
Other studies related to the condition(s) this trial covers.
- Can a psychedelic drug lift depression that won't budge?
- Brain implants and nerve stimulation put to the test for untreatable depression
- Fast brain stimulation shows promise for stubborn depression
- Ketamine booster for shock therapy? new trial aims to lift depression and protect memory
- Could an arthritis drug lift the fog of Treatment-Resistant depression?
- Can a gentler brain stimulation replace ECT for tough depression?